A Wrong Way to Scrapbook…

I recently attended a craft show and took my husband with me. He’s the kind of husband who comes along shopping and is more than happy to hold bags, will weigh in on colour choices during paper selection, doesn’t mind that we haven’t seen the kitchen table since we moved in together (3 years ago) and can identify an Inky Quill video from the opening bars of the theme song… ok I’m gushing like the newlywed I am, but my point is he is very pro craft. 

So when I asked him to do the scrapbooking class with me he didn’t hesitate. He selected two pictures to print on my selphy at home. He paid his $10 and took a seat. 

The class was for Azza, which was billed as “a European style of scrapbooking”. 

We sat down interested in trying something new, and that’s about the point the wheels came off. 

Upon producing our photos we were told they were wrong. They were immediately dismissed and replaced with stock photos. Being selphy prints I understand they are not true 6×4 prints but when you see the final layout you can see, I believe, that  it would have been possible to work with them. Or at the very least, even if they wouldn’t have ‘worked’ in the sense of making the planned design look its best, the instructor could have explained the issue and given us the choice. It could have been an opportunity to learn about how this form of​ scrapbooking works. 

​Next, my husband was told to use the grid template to cut his photo into three.

As I understand it, that is the style of Azza. You use plastic templates to cut shapes out of photos and cardstock and then use the same template to stick everything down. 

When he was finished, and turned to the instructor for the next step, he was immediately met with the exclamation that he had done it ‘wrong’. That he had ‘cut the legs off the bird and that was just wrong.’ It can’t be like that and so it went on. 

Amended to avoid the offending cut legs

If you compare my finished layout (the flower) to his (the bird) in the picture below you will see that he hadn’t cut them off and discarded them. The feet would just have been in the lower third, just as the cut bud in my photo appears in the lower third. My husband had taken time lining up the template and was careful in his cutting. He hadn’t just slashed through the pictures willynilly.

But no, it wasn’t acceptable. He was given a new picture, told to do it again and this time to not cut the legs off.  

The completed Azza layouts

Now the irony is that it was their picture, positioned in the hole they directed us to use, and so to follow the template precisely there was no way to make it work without cutting through the legs!
The rest of the lesson continued in a similar vein. On my layout the sticking down of the green strips wasn’t considered straight enough so it was lifted and she re did it. A fact that annoyed me because to my eye it was straight. And you will notice my husband’s layout is missing the ‘feature’ stencilled card. That’s because he mucked up the stencilling too….

And that brings me to the point of this post. In the moment, how do you as the student/maker gently but firmly rebuff such statements? My husband and I didn’t. We silently agreed with a look to take the path of least resistance and so we sat there like naughty school children, did as we were told and left after having a not very  enjoyable hour. (Yes it took a full hour to make those layouts!!!)

But upon reflection, I wonder whether that was that really the best option. It meant we were unhappy, the lady and her store got no sales from us and now the next person will likely have a similar experience.
The woman teaching us was obviously a lovely lady who loves her craft. But she was also one who couldn’t see past her own version of perfection to enable someone else to learn the craft. And she was the one that was wrong. I strongly believe there is no wrong when it comes to arts and crafts. Only preferences. 

It’s a shame, because at this point I am turned right off Azza, even though I tried it because I already do a combination of traditional scrapbooking and project life and thought this might be a nice bridge between the two. 

At least we only lost $20 and an hour! 

If you scrap by Azza Id love to hear about your experiences. Leave me a comment below or tag me on social media.

6 thoughts on “A Wrong Way to Scrapbook…

  1. Mel Barwise says:

    Ohhhh I feel for you so much,
    I would feel so deflated and honestly the very same,
    I am not a confrontational person and I would of been churning up inside everytime this person was correcting!
    This should not happen and I would be mortified if the folks ran out of the class
    I love seeing the smiles on my students faces and excitement for the craft if that’s not happening I would go out of my way to make them feel better about their project.
    This sounds a horrid experience, so sorry!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. darrelrob says:

    Thanks Mel. Churning up inside captures the way I was feeling perfectly! I’m sure this would never happen in your class – it really comes down to reading your students and allowing them to grow, doesn’t it!

    Like

  3. Shay Jansen says:

    Geesh I am so sorry you went through this…can you complain to the shop if you did it at a shop. Nothing is wrong in scrapbooking it is a very personal thing and if you and your hubby are happy with your photo’s an decorations then stuff her!!

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s